Top Qualities to Look for When Hiring a Nanny

The top qualities of a good nanny – from reliability and punctuality, to experience and qualifications…

January 2025

A professional photo of Chloe Rodwell (Domestic recruitment specialist). She is leaning on a wall holding a cup of tea.

AUTHOR
CHLOE RODWELL, director of Abode Staff Ltd

When it comes to hiring a nanny, finding someone with the right qualifications is essential. But beyond experience and certifications, there are certain personal qualities that set the best nannies apart. These traits not only ensure your children are well cared for but also make the nanny a valued part of your family. In this guide, we’ll explore the top qualities to look for when hiring a nanny and how these characteristics can make all the difference.


1. Genuine Love for Children

A great nanny isn’t just someone who can look after children—they’re someone who genuinely enjoys spending time with them. This passion often shines through in their interactions, whether they’re planning creative activities, reading stories, or simply engaging with children at their level.

Signs to Look For:

  • They speak enthusiastically about previous childcare roles.
  • They show patience and kindness when interacting with children during the interview or trial period.

2. Reliability and Punctuality

Parents need someone they can count on, especially when juggling busy schedules. A reliable nanny ensures your children’s routines run smoothly, and punctuality demonstrates respect for your family’s time.

Questions to Ask:

  • “Can you share an example of how you handled unexpected challenges in a previous role?”
  • “How do you plan your day to ensure timeliness?”

3. Adaptability and Problem-Solving Skills

Every family has its own routines, values, and challenges. A good nanny can adapt to your household’s unique needs while also thinking on their feet to handle unexpected situations, like a last-minute schedule change or a sick child.

Example: Imagine your child refuses to eat lunch. A great nanny won’t panic—they’ll calmly offer alternatives or find creative ways to encourage eating.


4. Strong Communication Skills

Clear and open communication is essential for a successful nanny-family relationship. This includes discussing your child’s progress, raising any concerns, and understanding your expectations.

Communication Tips:

  • Establish a regular check-in to discuss how things are going.
  • Ask for a daily or weekly update on activities, meals, and any milestones.

5. Proactive Approach to Childcare

The best nannies don’t just supervise—they actively engage with children and contribute to their development. They might plan educational activities, encourage creativity, or organise outdoor play to keep your little ones happy and healthy.

Activities to Expect:

  • Planning age-appropriate arts and crafts.
  • Reading books to enhance language skills.
  • Organising games that promote physical activity.

6. Experience and Relevant Qualifications

While personality traits are crucial, experience and training ensure the nanny has the skills to provide excellent care. Look for qualifications like:

  • Paediatric First Aid Certification: Essential for handling emergencies.
  • DBS Check: Ensures a clean criminal record.
  • Childcare Training: Such as CACHE Level 3 or equivalent qualifications.

7. Patience and Emotional Resilience

Caring for children requires immense patience and the ability to stay calm under pressure. Whether dealing with tantrums or sibling disagreements, a great nanny handles challenges with grace and composure.

Signs of Patience:

  • They can share examples of how they’ve diffused tense situations in the past.
  • They remain calm and focused during stressful scenarios.

8. Organisational Skills

From managing children’s schedules to preparing meals and keeping toys tidy, a good nanny stays organised to ensure your home runs smoothly.

Organisational Traits to Look For:

  • They arrive at interviews prepared with references and a detailed CV.
  • They can describe how they’ve juggled multiple responsibilities in previous roles.

9. Trustworthiness and Discretion

Your nanny will likely become privy to private aspects of your family’s life. It’s essential to hire someone who values confidentiality and demonstrates integrity.

How to Assess This Quality:

  • Request references that speak to the nanny’s character and professionalism.
  • Discuss scenarios during the interview to gauge their discretion.

10. A Sense of Fun and Creativity

Children thrive when they’re in an environment that encourages imagination and play. A nanny with a sense of fun can make everyday activities exciting and memorable.

Examples of Creativity:

  • Turning a rainy day into a craft project.
  • Organising a treasure hunt in the garden.
  • Inventing games to make learning enjoyable.

Conclusion

Hiring a nanny isn’t just about finding someone with experience—it’s about finding the right fit for your family. Look for qualities like reliability, adaptability, and a genuine love for children to ensure your nanny becomes a trusted and valuable part of your household. You might also like to read: The 5 Most Common Personality Traits of Great Nannies


A smiling nanny playing with a child and a dog at a park.
Scroll to Top